
Are Hotel Comparison Sites Cheaper? How Trivago and Google Hotels Choose the Price You See
A comparison site does not sell you the room. Knowing who does, and who paid for the top spot, is most of the saving
Are hotel comparison sites cheaper than booking direct? How trivago and Google Hotels pick the highlighted price, what the trivago court case found, and how to compare properly.
By Thomas Lovas Lokoy — drafted with AI assistance from the cited sources and edited for NorwegianSpark SA; not yet personally reviewed by Thomas. Editorial policy.
Hotel comparison sites are not cheaper in themselves, because they do not sell the room. Sites such as trivago and Google Hotels gather prices from booking sites and, where available, the hotel's own website, then send you to one of them to pay. That makes them a fast way to see many prices at once, but the price you pay is always set by the seller you click through to, and the offer a comparison site puts at the top is not guaranteed to be the cheapest one it has. In Australia, a court found that trivago's highlighted offer was often a higher price chosen partly because the booking site paid trivago more per click. Use comparison sites to find the field, then check the full list, compare like for like, and look at the hotel's own price before you pay.
Facts below were read on the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission's (ACCC) website, the UK government's Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) announcement and Google's own help pages on 12 November 2026; the sources are listed at the end. Aurevia Escapes may earn a commission if you book through the links on this page, at no extra cost to you; it does not change what we report.
Comparison site, booking site or hotel: who actually sells you the room
| Comparison (metasearch) site | Booking site (online travel agency) | Hotel's own website | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Examples | trivago, Google Hotels | Booking.com, Hotels.com, Expedia | The hotel or chain's official site |
| Sells you the room? | No, it sends you to a seller | Yes | Yes |
| Who you pay | Nobody at this step | The booking site, or the hotel if you choose pay at the property | The hotel |
| Who handles changes and refunds | The seller you booked with | The booking site, under the hotel's rate terms | The hotel |
| How it is paid | Fees from booking sites and hotels, such as cost per click or paid listings | Commission from the hotel | Your payment |
How the three channels fit together. Payment models as described by the ACCC (trivago) and Google (Google Hotels), read 12 November 2026.
That last row is the one to remember. A comparison site earns money when you click through to a seller, so the order in which it shows offers is a commercial decision as well as a helpful one. Nothing about that is hidden, but it is easy to forget when one price is displayed large and the rest sit behind a 'more deals' link.
What the trivago case found
The clearest public evidence of how a highlighted price can mislead comes from Australia. The ACCC brought proceedings against trivago in August 2018. In January 2020 the Federal Court found that trivago had breached the Australian Consumer Law by representing that its website would quickly and easily help users find the best deal or cheapest rates for a hotel. trivago's appeal was dismissed by the Full Federal Court in November 2020, and in April 2022 the court ordered it to pay A$44.7 million in penalties.
- How the top offer was chosen: according to the ACCC, trivago used an algorithm that placed significant weight on which online booking site paid it the highest cost-per-click fee when deciding which rate to highlight.
- How often it was not the cheapest: trivago's own data showed higher-priced rates were selected as the 'Top Position Offer' over lower-priced alternatives in 66.8 per cent of listings.
- What it cost consumers: trivago admitted that between December 2016 and September 2019 it received about A$58 million in cost-per-click fees from clicks on offers that were not the cheapest available, causing consumers to overpay booking sites about A$38 million.
- Strike-through prices: the ACCC said trivago also misled consumers with strike-through prices that often compared a standard room with a luxury room at the same hotel.
The case concerned trivago's Australian website and advertising, and it is a finding about conduct up to 2019, not a description of how any site works today. The lesson still applies everywhere: the big number at the top of a comparison is a recommendation, and the cheapest offer may be one click further down.
What UK regulators made booking sites change
In February 2019 the CMA announced that Expedia, Booking.com, Agoda, Hotels.com, ebookers and trivago had voluntarily given formal commitments after its investigation into pressure selling, misleading discount claims, the effect of commission on how hotels are ordered, and hidden charges. The sites agreed to say when search results have been affected by the commission a hotel pays, to stop giving a false impression of a room's popularity or availability, to make discount claims only against relevant prices, and to show all compulsory charges, such as taxes and booking or resort fees, in the headline price. The changes were due by 1 September 2019. The CMA was clear that it had not made a finding that the sites broke consumer law, and the undertakings were not an admission that they had.
Two practical habits follow. Look for the ranking explanation, often a line such as 'how we sort results', before treating the first result as the best. And treat urgency messages with care: the CMA's example was a 'others are looking at this hotel' message that did not make clear those people might be searching different dates.
How Google Hotels shows prices
Google publishes how its hotel search works, which makes it a useful benchmark. It says hotels do not pay to appear in hotel search results and cannot pay to influence their ranking; results are sorted by relevance using factors such as location, price and reviews, and may be personalised. The booking links are a separate matter. Partners can create booking links free of charge or for a fee. Paid links carry an 'Ads' badge and are listed as 'Featured options', ranked by an ad auction that weighs bid and ad quality, and Google may be paid when you click one or, in some cases, when you book. Free links are listed under 'All options'.
- The headline price on a hotel in the results list is the lowest price provided across Google's partners for that property.
- Under Google's Price Accuracy Policy, partners' prices must include taxes and fees and match the total on their booking page. Google still advises checking the final cost carefully, because prices change quickly.
- Some prices are 'customised' by the partner, varying by device, whether you are signed in, or membership of an audience list. Google marks these with an asterisk.
- Average prices, where shown, are the median rate over the next 90 days of availability, not the price for your dates.
- A 'Deal' badge means the hotel's price ratio against its own past year is at least 15% lower than that of similar hotels nearby; a 'Great Deal' means at least 25% lower.
The hotel's detail page also carries a direct link to the hotel's own website. That matters because some of the most useful hotel prices, such as member-only rates, appear only on the hotel's site after you sign in, and a comparison site may not show them at all. We cover member rates and when the hotel's own site wins in should you book a hotel direct or through Booking.com?.
Partner
Booking.com
Sign in before you search rather than after. Genius Level 1 applies from account creation, and the discounted rate is the one that belongs in any comparison you are running against another site.
How to use a hotel comparison site properly
- Search with your real dates and number of guests. Average or sample prices tell you little about your stay.
- Open the full list of offers for the hotel, not just the highlighted one: 'more deals', 'All options' or the equivalent.
- Compare like for like: the same room type, the same board basis and, above all, the same cancellation terms. A non-refundable rate at the top of a list is not comparable with a flexible rate further down; free cancellation vs non-refundable works through when the saving is worth it.
- Click through and check the total on the seller's final page before you pay, including any charge collected at the hotel, such as a city or tourist tax.
- Check the hotel's own website, signed in to its free loyalty programme if it has one, for a member rate.
- Book with the seller whose terms you are happiest dealing with, because that is the company you will contact for changes, cancellations and refunds.
Partner
Hotels.com
Worth pricing alongside Booking.com rather than instead of it. On the same property on the same dates the two frequently differ once taxes and fees are applied, and the difference is only visible at the final screen.
If something goes wrong, who do you call?
The seller, not the comparison site. Google says that customer service questions, including changes, cancellations and refunds, should go to the booking partner you booked with. The same logic applies to any comparison site: it introduced you, but your contract is with the booking site or the hotel. Keep the confirmation email from the seller, and if you paid a booking site, note whether you paid it or will pay the hotel on arrival, because that decides who holds your money; pay now or pay at the property explains the difference.
If you are comparing whole holidays rather than hotels, the question of who you contract with matters even more, because a flight and hotel sold together can be a package with legal protections that separate bookings do not have. See package holiday or book separately?.
The short version
- Comparison sites are search tools, not sellers. They are useful for finding the field, not proof of the lowest price.
- The highlighted offer can be influenced by what sellers pay. Open the full list.
- Compare totals with the same room, board and cancellation terms.
- Check the hotel's own website for a member rate before you book.
- Your contract, and your customer service, is with whoever takes your booking.
Sources
- ACCC media release 49/22, 'Trivago to pay $44.7 million in penalties for misleading consumers over hotel room rates', 22 April 2022 (accc.gov.au), read 12 November 2026.
- Competition and Markets Authority, 'Hotel booking sites to make major changes after CMA probe', published 6 February 2019 (gov.uk), read 12 November 2026.
- Google Travel Help, 'Hotel search on Google' (support.google.com), read 12 November 2026.
- Google Hotel Center Help, 'How travelers find hotel booking links' (support.google.com), read 12 November 2026.
Frequently asked questions
- Are hotel comparison sites cheaper than booking direct?
- Not in themselves. A comparison site does not sell rooms; it shows offers from booking sites and, sometimes, the hotel's own website, then sends you to one of them to pay. The price you pay is set by that seller. A comparison site helps you find the cheapest offer it knows about, but the highlighted offer is not always the cheapest one listed.
- Does trivago show the cheapest price?
- Not necessarily the one it highlights. In proceedings brought by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission, the Federal Court found in January 2020 that trivago's algorithm placed significant weight on which booking site paid it the highest cost-per-click fee, and that higher-priced rates were chosen as the top offer over lower-priced ones in 66.8 per cent of listings. trivago was ordered to pay A$44.7 million in penalties in April 2022. Always open the full list of offers.
- How does Google Hotels make money?
- Google says hotels do not pay to appear in hotel search results and cannot pay to influence their ranking. Booking links are different: partners can list them free or pay for them. Paid links carry an 'Ads' badge, sit under 'Featured options', are ranked by an ad auction, and Google may be paid when you click one or, in some cases, when you book.
- Do comparison site prices include taxes and fees?
- On Google Hotels, partners must send prices that include taxes and fees and match the total on their booking page, under Google's Price Accuracy Policy, though Google says prices can change quickly and you should check the final cost. Some charges, such as a city tax paid at the hotel, may still be collected on arrival, so read the final booking page.
- Who do I contact if something goes wrong with a booking made through a comparison site?
- The company you actually booked and paid with. Google, for example, says that changes, cancellations and refunds for bookings made through its links should be directed to the booking partner, not to Google.
Continue Reading
More from the Journal
Continue in this collection

Travel Planning
Budgeting, insurance and concierge services, judged on what they do when a trip goes wrong.

Travel Guides
Destination guides written to be used on the ground: where to stay, eat, and what to skip.

5-Star Hotels
What actually earns the fifth star, and which properties are coasting on one they were given years ago.




