How to Choose a 5-Star Hotel That’s Actually Worth It
Star ratings lie. Here’s how to evaluate a luxury hotel before you book — and how to get the best possible experience once you arrive.
Ignore the official star rating
Hotel star ratings are not globally standardised and can be deeply misleading. In France, stars are government-regulated and relatively reliable. In many other countries, the rating is self-declared or awarded by a local tourism board with minimal criteria. A five-star hotel in one country might genuinely rival the world’s best properties, while a five-star in another might barely meet three-star standards elsewhere. Some of the most exceptional hotels in the world — boutique properties, design hotels, and owner-operated gems — deliberately avoid the star system entirely because they do not want to be measured on checkbox criteria like room count or lobby size. Focus instead on independent review platforms, travel awards, and curated luxury hotel collections that apply consistent global standards.
📸 What to look for: Look for hotels that appear in curated collections like Virtuoso, Leading Hotels of the World, or Relais & Châteaux — these apply rigorous, consistent quality criteria.
Read 20+ recent reviews across multiple platforms
A handful of reviews can be misleading in either direction — both overly positive reviews from friends-and-family and angry reviews from unreasonable guests exist on every platform. To get an accurate picture, read at least 20 recent reviews (within the last six months) across TripAdvisor, Google Reviews, and the booking platform you plan to use. Look for patterns rather than individual complaints: if three separate guests mention tired bathrooms or slow service at breakfast, that is a real issue. Pay particular attention to reviews from travellers similar to you — a family of four has different needs than a honeymooning couple. Check responses from the hotel too: properties that respond thoughtfully to criticism are usually well-managed, while defensive or template responses suggest management does not genuinely care about guest feedback.
📸 What to look for: Sort reviews by “most recent” rather than “most relevant” — the algorithm’s idea of relevant may not match yours, and recent reviews reflect the current state of the hotel.
Check room size in square metres
Luxury should mean space, and room size is one of the most overlooked factors when booking a hotel. Many so-called luxury hotels in major cities offer rooms under 25 square metres, which feels cramped regardless of how beautiful the finishes are. Look for the room dimensions in the hotel’s own website or the booking platform’s property details — if they do not publish room size, that is often a sign the rooms are small. As a benchmark, a genuinely luxurious hotel room should be at least 35–40 square metres, and a suite should start at 55 square metres or more. Consider ceiling height too — a 40-square-metre room with three-metre ceilings feels dramatically different from one with standard 2.4-metre ceilings. Space is especially important if you plan to spend time in your room relaxing rather than just sleeping.
📸 What to look for: Use floor-plan images if available — they tell you more about usable space and layout than photographs, which are always shot with wide-angle lenses.
Confirm the specific room category you are booking
Hotel room naming is intentionally confusing and varies between brands. A “Deluxe Room” at one hotel might be their entry-level category, while at another it sits mid-range. “Junior Suite” sometimes means a genuine separate living area and sometimes means a slightly larger room with a sofa in the corner. Before you book, look at the hotel’s own website for floor plans or detailed descriptions of each room category. Compare the specific room you are booking against the next category up — the price difference is often smaller than you expect, and the upgrade in space, view, or amenities can be significant. Pay attention to view descriptions: “garden view” might mean a beautiful tropical garden, or it might mean the hotel’s service yard with a hedge in front of it. If the view matters to you, call and ask directly.
📸 What to look for: Book the room category one level above the cheapest — the entry-level room at a luxury hotel is often the one they struggle to fill upgrades from.
Check what breakfast actually includes
Breakfast is a surprisingly reliable indicator of a hotel’s overall quality and generosity. A genuinely luxurious hotel offers a full breakfast with freshly squeezed juices, an egg station with made-to-order omelettes and eggs Benedict, quality charcuterie and cheeses, fresh pastries baked on-site, local specialities, and good coffee from an espresso machine — not a pod. Hotels that advertise “continental breakfast included” at the luxury level are almost always cutting corners: continental means bread, jam, and coffee, which is not what you expect at a premium property. Check whether breakfast is included in your rate or charged separately, as a luxury hotel breakfast can cost 40–80 euros per person per day. If it is not included, factor that into your total cost comparison — it can add hundreds to a week-long stay.
📸 What to look for: Check recent photos tagged at the hotel on Instagram to see what breakfast actually looks like — promotional photos are usually styled, guest photos are real.
Call the hotel directly after booking
This is one of the simplest and most effective ways to improve your hotel experience, yet very few guests do it. After booking, call the hotel’s direct line (not the central reservation number) and introduce yourself. Mention your arrival date, any special occasion you are celebrating, and any preferences you have — a quiet room away from the lift, a higher floor, extra pillows, or a specific minibar setup. This call does two things: it flags you as an engaged guest who the hotel wants to impress, and it creates a personal connection with the reception or guest relations team before you arrive. Hotels track guest preferences in their property management system, and a pre-arrival call ensures your notes are in the system before your room is assigned. The difference in welcome between a guest who called ahead and one who did not is consistently noticeable.
📸 What to look for: Follow up the call with a brief email summarising your preferences — this ensures they are recorded in the system even if the person you spoke to forgets.
Arrive with a reasonable request
Hotels want guests to leave happy, and the front desk team has more discretion than most travellers realise. Arriving with a polite, specific, and reasonable request — rather than a vague hope — dramatically increases your chances of receiving something extra. Mentioning that it is your anniversary, your birthday, or your first visit to the hotel gives the team a reason to make a gesture: a bottle of wine in the room, a complimentary dessert at dinner, or a room upgrade if availability allows. The key word is reasonable — asking for a free suite upgrade on a sold-out Saturday night will get you nowhere, but asking whether a higher floor or a quieter room is available on a quiet Tuesday is entirely realistic. Be warm, be grateful, and never act as though you are owed anything. The guests who receive the most are consistently the ones who expect the least but ask the nicest.
📸 What to look for: If you receive an upgrade or amenity, mention the specific staff member by name in your review — it helps them and builds goodwill for your next visit.
Ready to Get Started?
Browse our trusted partners for the best rates and experiences.
Related Reading
Curated by Thomas & Øyvind — NorwegianSpark · Last updated: April 2026